You are hereThe following appeared as part of a letter to the editor of a scientific journal.A recent study of eighteen rhesus monkeys provides clues as to the effects of birth order on an individual's levels of stimulation. The study showed that in stimulating situa

The following appeared as part of a letter to the editor of a scientific journal.A recent study of eighteen rhesus monkeys provides clues as to the effects of birth order on an individual's levels of stimulation. The study showed that in stimulating situa


aloha871111's picture

By aloha871111 - Posted on 10 June 2012

Essay topic: 

The following appeared as part of a letter to the editor of a scientific journal.

A recent study of eighteen rhesus monkeys provides clues as to the effects of birth order on an individual's levels of stimulation. The study showed that in stimulating situations (such as an encounter with an unfamiliar monkey), firstborn infant monkeys produce up to twice as much of the hormone cortisol, which primes the body for increased activity levels, as do their younger siblings. Firstborn humans also produce relatively high levels of cortisol in stimulating situations (such as the return of a parent after an absence). The study also found that during pregnancy, first-time mother monkeys had higher levels of cortisol than did those who had had several offspring."

Write a response in which you discuss one or more alternative explanations that could rival the proposed explanation and explain how your explanation(s) can plausibly account for the facts presented in the argument.

In this letter, the author concludes that birth order and even being mother for the first time can affect individuals' levels of stimulation by citing a study of eighteen rhesus monkeys. At the first glance, this may be a newly exciting scientific breakthrough, however, after examining the evidence provided by the author, several other alternative explanations to the same issue could undermine the reliability of the conclusion.

The initial problem with this argument is the possible flaws in the study cited by the author. According to the introduction of the study, its subjects are eighteen rhesus monkeys. Yet, there is not quite possible that a convincing result of a study can be generated merely based on eighteen subjects. Because the size of the sample in this study is not big enough, and the smaller the sample, the less reliable the study's conclusion. Besides, the sample are selected from rhesus solely. However, can rhesus monkeys be the representative of the whole monkey species? Common sense informs people that monkey species include a rather wide range in the nature, perhaps distinct species have different physical and biological functions which may lead to the opposite outcomes. What's more, the author fails to offer the detail information of those monkeys such as their age, sex and etc. And opposite sex can decide different responses to the same environment, as well as different age. Unless the author takes into account all those possible alternative explanations, the study cited in the letter can only undermine its reliability by its own.

Another hidden flaw in the letter is that, the author simply equates the situation of the birth order with that of fist-time being mother. The author assumes that, according to the study in which the fist born monkeys can generate a high level of cortisol so can first-time mother monkeys, the cause and effect of the high level of cortisol between the first born monkeys and first-time mother monkeys are the same. However, other alternative explanations may cast doubts on this assumption. Perhaps, the reason that those first-time mother monkeys generate such a high level of cortisol may not result from the need that they have to regulate their activity levels to confront the stimulating environment but a type of self-regulation to balance internal levels of hormones. This scenario, if true, would serve to weaken the author's conclusion.

Even though the two possibilities mentioned above are proved to be true, however, the author hastily assumes that there is no alternative explanations for the similar responses generated by monkeys and humans. However, merely resting the assumption on the unilateral and superficial phenomenon is unconvincing and cursory. Even though monkeys and humans are all mammals and there is some inherent relationship between them, however, they are still two independent and utterly distinct kind of species which means their physical functions and structures can be total different. Therefore, without providing well-rounded and scientific research of humans and ruling out these and other possible explanations behind it, the author's conclusion can not be reasonably established.

To sum up, the internally physical and biological functions of animals and humans are extremely intricate that there are still mysterious problems can not be fully solved and understood. The conclusion made by the author rests barely on an inaccurate study and superficial phenomena which are irresponsible and non-scientific. To strengthen the argument, years' researches and comparsons are required and also a rigorous attitude to science.

Average: 8 (10 votes)
Tags
More essays by this user:

Society should identify those children who have special talents and provide training for them at an early age to develop their talents.Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the recommendation and explain your NewNewNew
A true university education encompasses far more than the narrow, specialized study of a single discipline. Only through exploring the broad spectrum of liberal arts courses can students become truly learned. aruna
A recent sales study indicates that consumption of seafood dishes in Bay City restaurants has increased by 30 percent during the past five years. Yet there are no currently operating city restaurants whose specialty is seafood. Moreover, the majority of f ezb sticky icon
GMAT Issue Writing Sample 21 essayking
GMAT Issue Writing Sample 40 GMAT800
“The autonomy of any country is based on the strength of its borders; if the number of illegal immigrants entering a country cannot be checked, both its economy and national identity are endangered. Because illegal immigrants pose such threats, every effo jesuskal sticky icon
Some people believe that in order to be effective, political leaders must yield to public opinion and abandon principle for the sake of compromise. Others believe that the most essential quality of an effective leader is the ability to remain consistently Ly Phuong Thao
Educational institutions should actively encourage their students to choose fields of study that will prepare them for lucrative careers.Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the claim. In developing and supp yjc1989
A nation should require all of its students to study the same national curriculum until they enter college. abadki sticky icon
The following was written by a group of developers in the city of Monroe."A jazz music club in Monroe would be a tremendously profitable enterprise. At present, the nearest jazz club is over 60 miles away from Monroe; thus, our proposed club, the C Note, RishiB sticky icon

Term
Argument Essay:-->In an attempt to improve highway safety, Prunty County last year lowered its speed limit from 55 to 45 miles per hour on all county highways. But this effort has failed: the number of accidents has not decreased, and, based on reports by smartaquarius10 GMAT/GRE
It is more harmful to compromise one's own beliefs than to adhere to them. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
“Responsibility for preserving the natural environment ultimately belongs to each individual person, not to government.” thakur.shikha1@... GMAT/GRE
Educational institutions have a responsibility to dissuade students from pursuing fields of study in which they are unlikely to succeed. wasainika17 GMAT/GRE
We can learn much more from people whose views we share than from people whose views contradict our own. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
The well-being of a society is enhanced when many of its people question authority.Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the statement and explain your reasoning for the position you take. In developing and s nilka61 GMAT/GRE
Claim: Colleges and universities should specify all required courses and eliminate elective courses in order to provide clear guidance for students.Reason: College students—like people in general—prefer to follow directions rather than make their own deci siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
As people rely more and more on technology to solve problems, the ability of humans to think for themselves will surely deteriorate.Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the statement and explain your reasoni nitishajain51 GMAT/GRE
Woven baskets characterized by a particular distinctive pattern have previously been found only in the immediate vicinity of the prehistoric village of Palea and therefore were believed to have been made only by the Palean people. Recently, however, archa aaish GMAT/GRE Argument Task
The most effective way to understand contemporary culture is to analyze the trends of its youth. sheepfei199184 GMAT/GRE

Term
Some people believe that universities should require every student to take a variety of courses outside the student's field of study. Others believe that universities should not force students to take any courses other than those that will help prepare t siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
It is more harmful to compromise one's own beliefs than to adhere to them. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
Claim: Colleges and universities should specify all required courses and eliminate elective courses in order to provide clear guidance for students.Reason: College students—like people in general—prefer to follow directions rather than make their own deci siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
We can learn much more from people whose views we share than from people whose views contradict our own. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
College students should be encouraged to pursue subjects that interest them rather than the courses that seem most likely to lead to jobs. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
The effectiveness of a country's leaders is best measured by examining the well-being of that country's citizens. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
The following appeared in a memorandum from the manager of WWAC radio station."To reverse a decline in listener numbers, our owners have decided that WWAC must change from its current rock-music format. The decline has occurred despite population growth i fred042102 GMAT/GRE Argument Task
In any field of inquiry, the beginner is more likely than the expert to make important contribution. Seyma Pekgoz GMAT/GRE Issue Task
To understand the most important characteristics of a society, one must study its major cities.(3) siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
Claim: Universities should require every student to take a variety of courses outside the student's major field of study. Reason: Acquiring knowledge of various academic disciplines is the best way to become truly educated. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task

The best leaders are those who encourage feedback from the people whom they lead. hsuyuchen8 GMAT/GRE Issue Task
To understand the most important characteristics of a society, one must study its major cities.(3) siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
Claim: Colleges and universities should specify all required courses and eliminate elective courses in order to provide clear guidance for students.Reason: College students—like people in general—prefer to follow directions rather than make their own deci siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
We can usually learn much more from people whose views we share than from people whose views contradict our own.Write a response in which you discuss the extent to which you agree or disagree with the statement and explain your reasoning for the position karenpeck GMAT/GRE Issue Task
The following appeared in a memorandum from the manager of WWAC radio station.“WWAC must change from its current rock-music format because the number of listeners has been declining, even though the population in our listening area has been growing. The p karenpeck GMAT/GRE Argument Task
We can learn much more from people whose views we share than from people whose views contradict our own. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
“A ten-year nationwide study of the effectiveness of wearing a helmet while bicycling indicates that ten years ago, approximately 35 percent of all bicyclists reported wearing helmets, whereas today that number is nearly 80 percent. Another study, however karenpeck GMAT/GRE Argument Task
Scandals are useful because they focus our attention on problems in ways that no speaker or reformer ever could. siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
Scandals are useful because they focus our attention on problems in ways that no speaker or reformer ever could. (4) siamakd GMAT/GRE Issue Task
Some people believe that college students should consider only their own talents and interests when choosing a field of study. Others believe that college students should base their choice of a field of study on the availability of jobs in that field. hsuyuchen8 GMAT/GRE Issue Task
aloha871111's picture

I think this one is a little bit professional and i can not actually find the flaws, so plz give me some advice,thx!

essayE-rater's picture

You got the point and argued properly.

flaws:
This is a new GRE essay topic which is a bit different to those arguments essays.

You don't need to find flaws from the arguments but are asked to 'discuss one or more alternative explanations that could rival the proposed explanation...'

Attribute Value Ideal
Score: 4.5 out of 6
Category: Good Excellent
No. of Grammatical Errors: 0 2
No. of Spelling Errors: 0 2
No. of Sentences: 23 15
No. of Words: 571 350
No. of Characters: 3012 1500
No. of Different Words: 256 200
Fourth Root of Number of Words: 4.888 4.7
Average Word Length: 5.275 4.6
Word Length SD: 2.804 2.4
No. of Words greater than 5 chars: 237 100
No. of Words greater than 6 chars: 174 80
No. of Words greater than 7 chars: 125 40
No. of Words greater than 8 chars: 82 20
Use of Passive Voice (%): 0 0
Avg. Sentence Length: 24.826 21.0
Sentence Length SD: 11.036 7.5
Use of Discourse Markers (%): 0.696 0.12
Sentence-Text Coherence: 0.309 0.35
Sentence-Para Coherence: 0.498 0.50
Sentence-Sentence Coherence: 0.094 0.07
Number of Paragraphs: 5 5

aloha871111's picture

thank you for replying

You are welcome!

dream2000's picture

You don't need trying to find out all flaws. 2 - 3 flaws are enough.